APOD 2005/11/04 colours of nebulae
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 10:56 pm
"... M78, is just below centre in this sharp wide field view, covering an area north of Orion's belt. At a distance of about 1,500 light-years, the bluish nebula itself is about 5 light-years across. Its blue tint is due to dust preferentially reflecting the blue light of hot, young stars in the region. Dark dust lanes and other nebulae can easily be traced through this gorgeous skyscraper that also includes the remarkable McNeil's Nebula -- a newly recognized nebula associated with the formation of a sun-like star."
If dust is "preferentially reflecting the blue light", then no blue light would arrive here on earth because it was reflected rather than transmitted, so this is a poor explanation for seeing a blue colour!
It seems to me that the explanation offered in APOD is in error because the phenomenon-explained differs significantly from the phenomenon-observed.
Scattering, rather than reflection, is likely the mechanism, and particle size in the dust cloud is critical. When blue light is scattered we see a red sunset. When orange to red light is scattered we see a blue moon, which is as rare as the expression "once in a blue moon" indicates because of the requirement for interceding particles of the right size.
I suggest that the blue colour we see is in light left over after Mie scattering removes the orange to red wavelengths, which indicates that a significant proportion of the particles in the cloud have at least one dimension in the order of twice the wavelength of 'visible wavelength's.
From my understanding, I suggest that "once in a blue moon" might be a (twice) daily event on mars, because of its dusty atmosphere (see RCartier.com).
If dust is "preferentially reflecting the blue light", then no blue light would arrive here on earth because it was reflected rather than transmitted, so this is a poor explanation for seeing a blue colour!
It seems to me that the explanation offered in APOD is in error because the phenomenon-explained differs significantly from the phenomenon-observed.
Scattering, rather than reflection, is likely the mechanism, and particle size in the dust cloud is critical. When blue light is scattered we see a red sunset. When orange to red light is scattered we see a blue moon, which is as rare as the expression "once in a blue moon" indicates because of the requirement for interceding particles of the right size.
I suggest that the blue colour we see is in light left over after Mie scattering removes the orange to red wavelengths, which indicates that a significant proportion of the particles in the cloud have at least one dimension in the order of twice the wavelength of 'visible wavelength's.
From my understanding, I suggest that "once in a blue moon" might be a (twice) daily event on mars, because of its dusty atmosphere (see RCartier.com).