Page 1 of 1
APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 4:09 am
by APOD Robot
Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower
Explanation: Where do Perseid meteors come from? Mostly small bits of stony grit,
Perseid meteoroids were once expelled from
Comet Swift-Tuttle and continue to follow this comet's orbit as they slowly disperse. The
featured animation depicts the entire meteoroid stream as it orbits
our Sun. When the Earth nears this stream, as it does every year, the
Perseid Meteor Shower occurs. Highlighted as bright in the animation,
comet debris this size is usually so dim it is practically undetectable. Only a small fraction of this debris will enter the
Earth's atmosphere, heat up and
disintegrate brightly. This weekend promises some of the better skies to view the
Perseid shower as well as
other active showers because the
new moon will not only be faint, it will be completely absent from the sky for most of the night. Although
not outshining faint Perseids, the new moon will partially obstruct the Sun as a
partial solar eclipse will be
visible from some northern locations.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 6:31 am
by rj rl
1/10 animation, ecliptic perpendicular to the galactic plane. Just kidding, it's quite beautiful.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 9:34 am
by De58te
Wikipedia said the ecliptic is 60 degrees to the galactic plane. So what would you call that geometrically? Almost perpendicular? What confuses me is that judging by the rotation of the planets that the north pole is towards the top. Yet the 'thicker' central disc of the Milky Way, which I know can only be seen in the Southern Hemisphere, here is located in the Northern Hemisphere. Although they did get the location of the Large Magellanic Cloud right.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:59 am
by neufer
De58te wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 9:34 am
Wikipedia said the ecliptic is 60 degrees to the galactic plane. So what would you call that geometrically? Almost perpendicular? What confuses me is that judging by the rotation of the planets that the north pole is towards the top. Yet the 'thicker' central disc of the Milky Way, which I know can only be seen in the Southern Hemisphere, here is located in the Northern Hemisphere. Although they did get the location of the Large Magellanic Cloud right.
We are looking
DOWN through the plane of the Solar System at an angle of roughly 45°
Hence:
- Sgr A* at Declination −29° should lie above the Sun and
the LMC at Declination −70° should lie below the Sun
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 11:24 am
by Dan
Go to the link under "featured animation" and go full screen.
Then in the upper left, select the "view" drop down and choose the second to last option "everything at once".
Click and drag... zoom in and out... Here's hoping you've got a decent video card. Enjoy.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 1:04 pm
by bls0326
The "featured animation" is quite busy, especially the "everything at once" option. Thanks for pointing it out Dan.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 4:27 pm
by Joe Stieber
Interestingly, there's a very bright and seemingly out-of-place object not far above the handle of the Sagittarius "Teapot" in the background sky (near the top of the picture as it opens, you may have to tilt the animation to see it). As best as I can tell, this is Jupiter in June of 2008. If so, Jupiter is in both the background sky and the foreground animation.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 4:31 pm
by tkl
This animation implies that the Perseid Meteor Shower would occur on the other planets in the solar system. Would this be true, assuming an atmosphere dense enough to allow for the meteor streak? Given the geometry, it seems the radiant would still be in the same general direction as Perseus.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 4:55 pm
by Lewis000000
I'm confused about the orientation of the solar system and the Milky Way (as others are/were). When I look at the animation with the solar system edge on, it still looks like the Milky Way is perpendicular to the plane of the ecliptic??? but I've never been good at 3 dimensional puzzles.
The animation is gorgeous nonetheless!
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_biggrin.gif)
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 6:35 pm
by Chris Peterson
tkl wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 4:31 pm
This animation implies that the Perseid Meteor Shower would occur on the other planets in the solar system.
No. The orbital plane of the Perseids is substantially different than that of the ecliptic. The Earth's orbit is the only one that intersects the Perseid debris cloud.
All the planets which have atmospheres also have meteor showers. But they are produced by different debris streams than those we encounter on Earth.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 8:52 pm
by MarkBour
I love this animation. It either "stood on the shoulders of giants", or took a lot of work to produce, I think. If I am not mistaken, every represented object in the foreground (except for the Sun, probably) is following a fine Keplerian orbit. And these are no doubt carefully built on current science data (This is Sparta! APOD!). Perhaps there is massive calculation going on to render those orbit positions.
At first I thought the planets were not moving at the appropriate speeds as they reached their aphelia and perihelia, but after I moved the animation around a bit, I discovered that the error was mine. The apparent shortening of distances and angular velocities to an observer for objects that are far away (i.e. on the far side of Sol) as opposed to their apparent distances and angular velocities when closer to the observer (i.e. on the near side of Sol) are causing this impression, I think. This did not occur to me until I watched and manipulated the simulation for a bit, but I am guessing it is quite correct. (I'd love to see some of the code for this.)
If so, then this is the first time I've seen an animation that taught me this feature of what an orbit would really look like ... if our eyes were able to see such a thing from such distances.
This illusion did not occur when observing the comet debris; I could tell that they were gaining speed as they approached Sol and losing it again on the way out. But their orbits are much more elongated.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:13 pm
by Chris Peterson
MarkBour wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 8:52 pm
I love this animation. It either "stood on the shoulders of giants", or took a lot of work to produce, I think. If I am not mistaken, every represented object in the foreground (except for the Sun, probably) is following a fine Keplerian orbit. And these are no doubt carefully built on current science data (This is
Sparta! APOD!). Perhaps there is massive calculation going on to render those orbit positions.
There are thousands of meteor cameras operating every night around the world. When you have a meteor on any pair of them (or more), the orbit is automatically calculated. The CAMS system that collected this data is particularly high resolution, since it utilizes multiple cameras. But the technique is the same. It's not a terribly complex calculation to derive an orbit from a meteor track, and there are now libraries with millions of calculated orbits.
That data goes into another fairly straightforward routine that renders a visual orbit from a set of orbital elements. There's a lot of data, which means a lot of calculations are going on, but that's all.
BTW, there is some confusing language in today's caption. This is not the entire debris stream, but rather, particles which have already been destroyed by their collision with Earth's atmosphere- only the tiniest fraction of the entire debris stream. In reality, none of these particles should be seen surviving their encounter with Earth and coming out the other side. We're seeing their orbits as if the Earth were not there.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:24 pm
by neufer
Chris Peterson wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:13 pm
This is not the entire debris stream, but rather, particles which have already been destroyed by their collision with Earth's atmosphere- only the tiniest fraction of the entire debris stream. In reality, none of these particles should be seen surviving their encounter with Earth and coming out the other side. We're seeing their orbits as if the Earth were not there.
One
samples the particles which are being destroyed by their collision with
Earth's atmosphere (as in a political poll) in order to predict the larger overall stream.
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:32 pm
by Chris Peterson
neufer wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:24 pm
Chris Peterson wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:13 pm
This is not the entire debris stream, but rather, particles which have already been destroyed by their collision with Earth's atmosphere- only the tiniest fraction of the entire debris stream. In reality, none of these particles should be seen surviving their encounter with Earth and coming out the other side. We're seeing their orbits as if the Earth were not there.
One
samples the particles which are being destroyed by their collision with
Earth's atmosphere (as in a political poll) in order to predict the larger overall stream.
One can do that. But that's not what we're seeing here. This is simply the orbits of the Perseids detected by the CAMS network. (If the entire debris stream were shown, we'd see nothing but white with the meteoroids represented at this size.)
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 11:07 pm
by saturno2
I like me very much the virtual animation
Re: APOD: Animation: Perseid Meteor Shower (2018 Aug 08)
Posted: Thu Aug 09, 2018 6:06 pm
by MarkBour
Chris Peterson wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:13 pm
MarkBour wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 8:52 pm
I love this animation. It either "stood on the shoulders of giants", or took a lot of work to produce, I think. If I am not mistaken, every represented object in the foreground (except for the Sun, probably) is following a fine Keplerian orbit. And these are no doubt carefully built on current science data (This is
Sparta! APOD!). Perhaps there is massive calculation going on to render those orbit positions.
There are thousands of meteor cameras operating every night around the world. When you have a meteor on any pair of them (or more), the orbit is automatically calculated. The CAMS system that collected this data is particularly high resolution, since it utilizes multiple cameras. But the technique is the same. It's not a terribly complex calculation to derive an orbit from a meteor track, and there are now libraries with millions of calculated orbits.
Wow, I didn't know they number in the thousands, nor that the number of calculated orbits would now be in the millions.
I know that you contribute to this with meteor cams and computing that you have at cloudbait and elsewhere.
Chris Peterson wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:13 pm
That data goes into another fairly straightforward routine that renders a visual orbit from a set of orbital elements. There's a lot of data, which means a lot of calculations are going on, but that's all.
I guess you're right to say: "fairly straightforward routine", and I suppose to animators this is all in a day's work. I don't know if there needs to be any specialization of rendering software to handle distances of millions of kilometers versus a room or a city block. Perhaps not. But it is still marvelous to me, for sure.
One thing I assume the animation software did *not* do was to compute the time delay for light to travel from each object to the observer. That is one thing that would differ in an animation on this scale versus a scene in a room. I assume we would rather see them where we think they "really are" and not add that complication to the rendering.
Chris Peterson wrote: ↑Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:13 pm
BTW, there is some confusing language in today's caption. This is not the entire debris stream, but rather, particles which have already been destroyed by their collision with Earth's atmosphere- only the tiniest fraction of the entire debris stream. In reality, none of these particles should be seen surviving their encounter with Earth and coming out the other side. We're seeing their orbits as if the Earth were not there.
Also interesting that these are all ghosts! The Earth is at work, cleaning out Perseids, Leonids, etc. (doing its job as a planet). I don't suppose one could detect any "cleaned up" regions in the streams ... there is probably a lot of randomization filling back in.