Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 6:26 am
by Boomer12k
Last part is interesting...
:---[===] *
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 7:26 am
by Ann
Interesting video.
Two things make Terzan 5 stand out. One, it contains ~12 billion year old stars as well as ~5 billion years old ones. That is certainly mysterious.
Two, it appears to be located relatively deep inside the Milky Way's disk.
Let's star with 2), the location of Terzan 5. I can't believe this globular has spent most of its life well inside the disk of the Milky Way. If it had been colliding with giant molecular clouds and other stuff in the disk for the better part of 12 billion years, I can't believe that Terzan 5 would still have existed as a cluster. That's why I think that Terzan 5 is just passing through.
Is it possible, though, that Terzan's probable passages through the disk of the Milky Way may have injected new gas into Terzan 5 and triggered star formation?
I'm reminded what I read about globular cluster NGC 6397 passing through the disk of the Milky Way, thereby possibly triggering the formation of massive open cluster NGC 6231.
But of course, a globular cluster forming new stars in itself is not the same thing as triggering star formation elsewhere.
Open cluster NGC 6231.
Photo: Josef Pöpsel, Stefan Binnewies of Capella Observatory.
Ann
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 9:23 am
by Guest
Ann wrote:Let's star with 2), the location of Terzan 5. I can't believe this globular has spent most of its life well inside the disk of the Milky Way. If it had been colliding with giant molecular clouds and other stuff in the disk for the better part of 12 billion years, I can't believe that Terzan 5 would still have existed as a cluster. That's why I think that Terzan 5 is just passing through.
When you say 'passing thru', do you mean to imply that it may be in some form of orbit around our galaxy interacting a 7 billion year intervals, or that the cluster is blasting thru only once with ballistic motion like a cluster-bullet from a universe-gun?
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 12:23 pm
by Straussl
We need to understand how an (apparently) simpler explanation might have been excluded: that this two-population cluster formed by merger of two clusters, one of age 11-12 Gyr and one of age 4-5 Gyr. /LCS
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 1:23 pm
by rstevenson
Guest wrote:
Ann wrote:Let's star with 2), the location of Terzan 5. I can't believe this globular has spent most of its life well inside the disk of the Milky Way. If it had been colliding with giant molecular clouds and other stuff in the disk for the better part of 12 billion years, I can't believe that Terzan 5 would still have existed as a cluster. That's why I think that Terzan 5 is just passing through.
When you say 'passing thru', do you mean to imply that it may be in some form of orbit around our galaxy interacting a 7 billion year intervals, or that the cluster is blasting thru only once with ballistic motion like a cluster-bullet from a universe-gun?
"Terzan 5 probably follows an unknown complicated orbit around the center of the galaxy, but currently it is moving towards the Sun with a speed of around 90 km/s." - Wikipedia article
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 7:07 pm
by Asterhole
It gives you some sense of the scale of our Galaxy, for sure. Globular clusters are tremendously large, but microscopic in comparison.
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 9:20 pm
by Just Jackson
In the completely zoomed in picture of the cluster, the entire left side appears composed of huge overlapping circular structures; like giant curved gaps, some containing lines of stars. The right side seems to have the expected appearance of a globular cluster; making an artifact unlikely as the cause of these "bubbles."
Comments? Does anyone else see / understand this, or do I need to re-install my browser again?
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Thu Sep 22, 2016 12:22 am
by ta152h0
ok, you win. Convinced me I am just a puny something
Re: APOD: Zooming in on Star Cluster Terzan 5 (2016 Sep 21)
Posted: Thu Sep 22, 2016 1:16 pm
by suicidejunkie
If you're focused and patient, you can see it zoom back out after the video ends