Neanderthal in all
Posted: Fri May 07, 2010 11:44 am
"Short, beetle-browed, powerfully built, with no chin and large (ears)." =>
---------------------------------
Neanderthal in all of us, DNA study indicates
David Perlman, SF Chronicle Science Editor
Friday, May 7, 2010
<<Only 10 years after scientists triumphantly decoded the human genome, an international research team has mapped the genes of the long-extinct Neanderthal people and report there's a little bit of Neanderthal in all of us. The remarkable finding could answer a question that has been hotly debated among anthropologists for decades: whether our human ancestors and the Neanderthals interbred some time after both species left Africa many thousands of years ago.
The report, published today in the journal Science, capped more than five years of intensive work by a group of 56 international scientists led by German paleogeneticist Svante Pääbo and Richard E. Green of UC Santa Cruz. Edward M. "Eddy" Rubin, director of the Department of Energy's Joint Genome Institute in Walnut Creek, called the major project "a terrific piece of work and a monumental endeavor,"
The project's scientists used tiny specks of powdered bone retrieved from three Neanderthal females who died in a Croatian cave more than 40,000 years ago to complete the draft of the Neanderthal genome. They then compared the genes to those of modern humans living today in five different regions of the world: France, Papua New Guinea, China, and southern and northern Africa.
Among their conclusions:
-- Humans living today carry between 1 and 4 percent of Neanderthal genes that carry the code for proteins in our bodies.
-- Those genes must have entered our lineage sometime during a 50,000-year period when the Neanderthals and humans left Africa through the Middle East and spread throughout Europe and Asia. The Neanderthals became extinct about 30,000 years ago.
-- The complete genomes of the Neanderthals and modern humans, whose lineages separated from some unknown common ancestor at least 400,000 years ago, are 99.5 percent identical. They are, in fact, our closest evolutionary relatives. By comparison, humans and chimpanzees share 98 percent of their genes.
The scientists analyzed 4 billion units of Neanderthal DNA, called nucleotides - at least 60 percent of the Neanderthal's entire genome. While incomplete, Pääbo told reporters during a teleconference this week that 60 percent "is a very good statistical sample of the entire genome."
Finding the Neanderthal genes in people living today provides "compelling" evidence that thousands of years ago some interbreeding occurred between the two species, Green said. "The sequencing of Neanderthal genetic material is real gold because we can now compare the Neanderthal genome with our own and pinpoint the genetic changes that have enabled humans to thrive, to spread across the entire globe, and to occupy every ecological niche that exists in the world," he said.
Green's group reported finding at least five genes in modern humans where natural selection apparently gave humans an evolutionary advantage over the Neanderthals. They include genes involved in mental development, in converting food into energy, and in developing the skull, the rib cage, and other parts of the human skeleton. In some of those genes lie many of the reasons the Neanderthals appear so different from humans despite the similarity of our genomes. Archaeologists have described them as short, beetle-browed, powerfully built, with no chin and large noses. Yet they made sophisticated stone tools and used animal skins for clothing.
Detecting the genes of the Neanderthals, dead so long ago, has been notoriously difficult because their bones have long been overwhelmingly contaminated by microbial infection. But the technology for isolating genetic material from ancient tissue has advanced so swiftly in recent years to make it feasible, Green said. Pääbo and his colleagues reported isolating the first few snippets of Neanderthal genes only four years ago. At that same time, Rubin and his colleagues at the Genome Institute in Walnut Creek reported sequencing a small group of similar Neanderthal genes using a different technique.
Rubin was not part of the Pääbo team, but after reading the new report, he was impressed. "It's the first glimpse of a freeway for us to go back and forth between the Neanderthal genome and ours to study our own evolution," he said.
However, Richard G. Klein, a noted archaeologist at Stanford who has long worked on the evolution of Neanderthals and humans, has serious reservations about the work. He is known for his research into the fossil record showing how modern humans replaced the Neanderthals throughout Europe thousands of years ago. The Pääbo group's report, he said, "contradicts everything we know about the archaeological record. Their evidence is really wobbly and it bothers me a lot. But it's very important stuff if it's right - and I really do hope it's right.">>
---------------------------------
---------------------------------
Neanderthal in all of us, DNA study indicates
David Perlman, SF Chronicle Science Editor
Friday, May 7, 2010
<<Only 10 years after scientists triumphantly decoded the human genome, an international research team has mapped the genes of the long-extinct Neanderthal people and report there's a little bit of Neanderthal in all of us. The remarkable finding could answer a question that has been hotly debated among anthropologists for decades: whether our human ancestors and the Neanderthals interbred some time after both species left Africa many thousands of years ago.
The report, published today in the journal Science, capped more than five years of intensive work by a group of 56 international scientists led by German paleogeneticist Svante Pääbo and Richard E. Green of UC Santa Cruz. Edward M. "Eddy" Rubin, director of the Department of Energy's Joint Genome Institute in Walnut Creek, called the major project "a terrific piece of work and a monumental endeavor,"
The project's scientists used tiny specks of powdered bone retrieved from three Neanderthal females who died in a Croatian cave more than 40,000 years ago to complete the draft of the Neanderthal genome. They then compared the genes to those of modern humans living today in five different regions of the world: France, Papua New Guinea, China, and southern and northern Africa.
Among their conclusions:
-- Humans living today carry between 1 and 4 percent of Neanderthal genes that carry the code for proteins in our bodies.
-- Those genes must have entered our lineage sometime during a 50,000-year period when the Neanderthals and humans left Africa through the Middle East and spread throughout Europe and Asia. The Neanderthals became extinct about 30,000 years ago.
-- The complete genomes of the Neanderthals and modern humans, whose lineages separated from some unknown common ancestor at least 400,000 years ago, are 99.5 percent identical. They are, in fact, our closest evolutionary relatives. By comparison, humans and chimpanzees share 98 percent of their genes.
The scientists analyzed 4 billion units of Neanderthal DNA, called nucleotides - at least 60 percent of the Neanderthal's entire genome. While incomplete, Pääbo told reporters during a teleconference this week that 60 percent "is a very good statistical sample of the entire genome."
Finding the Neanderthal genes in people living today provides "compelling" evidence that thousands of years ago some interbreeding occurred between the two species, Green said. "The sequencing of Neanderthal genetic material is real gold because we can now compare the Neanderthal genome with our own and pinpoint the genetic changes that have enabled humans to thrive, to spread across the entire globe, and to occupy every ecological niche that exists in the world," he said.
Green's group reported finding at least five genes in modern humans where natural selection apparently gave humans an evolutionary advantage over the Neanderthals. They include genes involved in mental development, in converting food into energy, and in developing the skull, the rib cage, and other parts of the human skeleton. In some of those genes lie many of the reasons the Neanderthals appear so different from humans despite the similarity of our genomes. Archaeologists have described them as short, beetle-browed, powerfully built, with no chin and large noses. Yet they made sophisticated stone tools and used animal skins for clothing.
Detecting the genes of the Neanderthals, dead so long ago, has been notoriously difficult because their bones have long been overwhelmingly contaminated by microbial infection. But the technology for isolating genetic material from ancient tissue has advanced so swiftly in recent years to make it feasible, Green said. Pääbo and his colleagues reported isolating the first few snippets of Neanderthal genes only four years ago. At that same time, Rubin and his colleagues at the Genome Institute in Walnut Creek reported sequencing a small group of similar Neanderthal genes using a different technique.
Rubin was not part of the Pääbo team, but after reading the new report, he was impressed. "It's the first glimpse of a freeway for us to go back and forth between the Neanderthal genome and ours to study our own evolution," he said.
However, Richard G. Klein, a noted archaeologist at Stanford who has long worked on the evolution of Neanderthals and humans, has serious reservations about the work. He is known for his research into the fossil record showing how modern humans replaced the Neanderthals throughout Europe thousands of years ago. The Pääbo group's report, he said, "contradicts everything we know about the archaeological record. Their evidence is really wobbly and it bothers me a lot. But it's very important stuff if it's right - and I really do hope it's right.">>
---------------------------------
