APOD and General Astronomy Discussion Forum
https://asterisk.apod.com/
I considered pointing that out earlier, but decided I might have already used up my testiness budget for the day... <g>owlice wrote:Well, sure; that's why it's one of the links in the APOD text....Guest wrote:great find! :Dgeomousey wrote:http://www.atoptics.co.uk/fz505.htm
provides a good explanation
That is incorrect. "Venusian" is certainly a word, and most dictionaries (every dictionary I checked) offer it as either the preferred or the only adjective when referring to the planet Venus. "Venereal" used to be the adjective commonly used, but that usage has largely disappeared, probably because of the more recent association of "venereal" with sexually transmitted diseases.JEpley wrote:"Venusian" is not a word. The correct term is "venereal".
Americans have a way of inventing/using new derivative forms, that are unknown in traditional English, to the point where they are entered into dictionaries.JEpley wrote:"Venusian" is not a word. The correct term is "venereal".
It is not incorrect to use a word generally considered obsolete. There are times to do just that (which demonstrates that in the English language, there are very few rules that define in an absolute sense what is or is not correct).owlice wrote:Actually, "venereal" is incorrect, though had/had been championed by a few writers, notably Heinlein. The OED lists the adjective venusian as meaning "Of, pertaining to, or characteristic of the planet Venus or its supposed inhabitants," and cites usage as early as 1874. (Another definition provided is "Of or pertaining to Venusia, an ancient town in southern Italy, and birthplace of the poet Horace; hence used allusively.") Venerean, with cited usage as early as 1575, is listed as obsolete; the OED has its meaning as "1. Connected or associated with, relating or pertaining to, Venus or her service." Venerian, meaning "1.a. Influenced by, subject to, Venus; inclined to wantonness.," is also listed as obsolete.
)
Quite so. Hopefully it is obvious I meant "venereal".owlice wrote:There is no meaning of "venerean" which means "of, pertaining to, or characteristic of the planet Venus."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cytherean wrote:
<<Cytherean is an adjective meaning pertaining to Cythera (Greek Κύθηρα, also transliterated Kythera or Kithira) , a small island now part of Greece, southeast of the Peloponnesus. It is also an adjective meaning pertaining to the planet Venus.
When planetary scientists began to have a need to discuss Venus in detail, an adjective was needed. Based on Latin principles, the correct adjectival form of the name would be Venerean. However, this term has an unfortunate similarity to the word venereal as in venereal diseases (related to "Venerean" as martial is to "Martian"), and is not generally used by astronomers. The term Venusian is etymologically messy (similar to saying "Earthian" or "Jupiterian"), and a "cleaner" version was desired.
It was suggested that since Venus had a Greek name, as well as a Roman one, this should be used; however, the adjectival form of Aphrodite was "aphrodisial", which again was felt to be unfortunately close to "aphrodisiac", again evoking matters not directly pertaining to astronomy.
A compromise was reached. In Greek mythology, the goddess Aphrodite was said to have been born from the sea, from which she emerged on a sea shell at the island of Cythera, and as such was sometimes known as Cytherea. The adjective Cytherean was taken from this name and remained popular in scientific literature for some time.
The term has since fallen out of common use. Venusian is the form most frequently used, with others, including Venerean appearing from time to time; the term Cytherean is now mostly found in older scientific papers, but some scientists still stick to the "tasteful" naming. In addition, the word "Cytherean" as an adjective referring to Venus is often found in science fiction of the early and mid 20th century.>>
Hence the acknowledgement in the phrase "classically correct" form in my original post about this, but ya know, sometimes the correct Latin adjectival form just doesn't suit.neufer wrote:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cytherean wrote: Based on Latin principles, the correct adjectival form of the name would be Venerean.
Like Washingtonians:owlice wrote:
English: It's messy, but it works.
Wouldn't you be 'depressed' if you were that close to ice cream and couldn't eat anyowlice wrote:Looks like Depression glass under that ice cream.
owlice wrote:Looks like Depression glass under that ice cream.
According to the OED it does ("of or relating to the planet Venus"). It indicates the usage is obsolete, but that doesn't make it wrong. Nevertheless, for the reasons I gave earlier, I wouldn't use it in discussing Venus outside of some literary context ("the twilight had an air surreal/colored by the light venereal").owlice wrote:Chris, I didn't even catch the error! Yes, it was obvious you meant venereal. Still, the point remains: venereal does not refer to "of, pertaining to, or characteristic of the planet Venus," either.
No it doesn't! "Venus or her service" -- you really think that refers to the planet??Chris Peterson wrote:According to the OED it does ("of or relating to the planet Venus"). It indicates the usage is obsolete, but that doesn't make it wrong. Nevertheless, for the reasons I gave earlier, I wouldn't use it in discussing Venus outside of some literary context ("the twilight had an air surreal/colored by the light venereal").owlice wrote:Chris, I didn't even catch the error! Yes, it was obvious you meant venereal. Still, the point remains: venereal does not refer to "of, pertaining to, or characteristic of the planet Venus," either.
I'm not sure I follow. My OED uses exactly the words I previously quoted (which is why I used quotes): "of or relating to the planet Venus". I may be mistaken, but that does sound to me like the planet is what is being referred to. And that is the only definition shown as obsolete- the ones that appear to refer to the goddess do not.owlice wrote:No it doesn't! "Venus or her service" -- you really think that refers to the planet?? :shock:Chris Peterson wrote:According to the OED it does ("of or relating to the planet Venus"). It indicates the usage is obsolete, but that doesn't make it wrong. Nevertheless, for the reasons I gave earlier, I wouldn't use it in discussing Venus outside of some literary context ("the twilight had an air surreal/colored by the light venereal").
Where's the falling over smilie? That's the one I need here!
(Chris, you are kidding, yes? Pulling my leg?)
owlice wrote:
Chris, maybe it's a difference between editions. I thought you were quoting my quote from the OED, which implies (pretty strongly) that venereal relates to the goddess, and says outright that venusian refers to the planet.
http://www.unmannedspaceflight.com/index.php?showtopic=6615&st=15 wrote:
<<The -al derivations (on the Latin Genitive) correspond to attributes associated with the astrological influence of the planet. Hence we have mercurial, venereal, martial, and jovial, (but saturnine, not saturnal) and we don't have uranal, neptunal, or cereal. (Not with those meanings, anyway.)
The -an derivations (also from the Latin Genitive) refer to properties of the planet itself, as I said earlier. To argue otherwise, you have to claim that ALL of the adjectives for the planets are "preoccupied" somehow, and this is clearly absurd.>> --Greg
