too many Reflections on the Inner Solar System

[christopher antonsen]

Why are there more reflections on the surface of the water than appear in the sky? Seems to be a bit too much massaging of the image here.

[makc]

what image?

[William Roeder]

He's refering to Reflections on the Inner Solar System

In it you can see the near horrizon with structures in the reflection but can't see them above. You should see the red sunset in the reflection but don't.

[christopher antonsen]

actually, there are more celestial bodies refltected on the water surface than appear in the sky. I suspect that the author of this photo did too much making the sky good for his submission and wiped out Venus in order to make a more asthetically pleasing image. but this is a scientific forum, one that I encourage my kid's to visit, and such image falsification kind of burns my rear end (how's my political correctness on that - will the FCC be upset?). anyway, there are 3 major celestial bodies reflected, but only the moon and Mercury in the sky!

[Boldra]

anyway, there are 3 major celestial bodies reflected, but only the moon and Mercury in the sky!

Are you talking about these lights below the moon? They are also the moon, reflected again because of ripples on the water.

Boldra

[makc]

In it you can see the near horrizon with structures in the reflection but can't see them above. You should see the red sunset in the reflection but don't.

It's reflection of grass sticking out of the water. You should see the red sunset in the reflection right behind this grass, but you don't just like you don't see grass itself - because it's too dark, or because there's too much grass.

I would agree with Boldra on ripples and moon (though his image does not its best for an illustration).