I'm not sure if it's thought to be general for most moons, but it is definitely thought to be one of the processes for their formation. In the Solar System, this process has been advocated for Charon, too.Sandstone wrote: My question, up for anyone who wants it: many planets have moons... and, while I'm not well-read on the subject, my impression has been that this theory (huge planet-sized impact ejecting and fragmenting off material to form the moon) has only been advocated for earth's moon. Do we have a reason to think that we have a "special case" scenario here? Or is this thought to be a general process for most moons?
APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Treating the word 'evolution' as if it is a religiously sacred concept, that applies ONLY to Darwinism, is what's confusing you and your students. On the contrary, it's a common everyday kind of concept.Ever try to teach evolution to a person who has a preconceived incorrect notion of what it is? This flippant use of the word "evolution" contaminates my students' brains, as well as the national discussion of science in general. I stand by my comment.
- Anthony Barreiro
- Turtles all the way down
- Posts: 793
- Joined: Wed May 11, 2011 7:09 pm
- Location: San Francisco, California, Turtle Island
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
What a lovely video. I'm going to share it with friends who love looking at the Moon. And the other LRO tour of the Moon video is pretty cool, too.
I enjoyed the music and the sound effects, but I don't have any cats here at work.
In the Random House Dictionary, the first definition of "evolution" is "any process of change or growth; development." Darwinian evolution is the third definition. If I were teaching Darwin's theory of evolution, I would probably start by discussing the general use of the term and clarifying its special meaning in biology. Students learn more when you relate something new to something they already know.
For what it's worth, Mercury, Mars, and Saturn are all retrograde currently, and Venus is approaching retrograde. Given the level of vitriol on Starship Asterisk currently, I'm looking forward to reading some fulminating screeds about astrology! (Is there an emoticon for <poking with a sharp stick>? Tee hee.)
I enjoyed the music and the sound effects, but I don't have any cats here at work.
In the Random House Dictionary, the first definition of "evolution" is "any process of change or growth; development." Darwinian evolution is the third definition. If I were teaching Darwin's theory of evolution, I would probably start by discussing the general use of the term and clarifying its special meaning in biology. Students learn more when you relate something new to something they already know.
For what it's worth, Mercury, Mars, and Saturn are all retrograde currently, and Venus is approaching retrograde. Given the level of vitriol on Starship Asterisk currently, I'm looking forward to reading some fulminating screeds about astrology! (Is there an emoticon for <poking with a sharp stick>? Tee hee.)
May all beings be happy, peaceful, and free.
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Rocky planets with moons
Earth - Luna
Believed to have been reformed after a catastrophic impact
Mars - Phobos
------- Deimos
Both are likely captured asteroids
Pluto - Charon (could be similar to Luna)
-------- Nix (unknown)
-------- Hydra (unknown)
-------- P4 (unknown)
Nix, Hydra, & newly discovered P4 could be remnants of a possible impact that created Charon
New Horizons might answer some or none of these questions
The remaining bulk of large Moons orbit Gas Giants or Ice Giants. It is unlikely that an impact of a gas giant would produce a viable stable rocky moon so they might have formed along side their planetary hosts during the accretion process
Earth - Luna
Believed to have been reformed after a catastrophic impact
Mars - Phobos
------- Deimos
Both are likely captured asteroids
Pluto - Charon (could be similar to Luna)
-------- Nix (unknown)
-------- Hydra (unknown)
-------- P4 (unknown)
Nix, Hydra, & newly discovered P4 could be remnants of a possible impact that created Charon
New Horizons might answer some or none of these questions
The remaining bulk of large Moons orbit Gas Giants or Ice Giants. It is unlikely that an impact of a gas giant would produce a viable stable rocky moon so they might have formed along side their planetary hosts during the accretion process
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Interesting vid, but I have two very basic questions I feel embarrassed to ask.
My first question is; would material 'expelled' from early-history Earth automatically be pulled back into an Earth orbit at a certain distance from the Earth proportionate to it's mass?
And a second question; from where exactly on Earth was this massive chunk of Earth expelled?
Thanks in advance.
My first question is; would material 'expelled' from early-history Earth automatically be pulled back into an Earth orbit at a certain distance from the Earth proportionate to it's mass?
And a second question; from where exactly on Earth was this massive chunk of Earth expelled?
Thanks in advance.
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
is there another place than youtube to view the link behind the words "impacted the earth"? Youtube will not show that in germany due to ownership issues regarding the music
Thanks in advance,
Peter
![Crying or Very sad :cry:](./images/smilies/icon_cry.gif)
Thanks in advance,
Peter
in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gadus ... PG">cod</a> we trust
- Chris Peterson
- Abominable Snowman
- Posts: 18460
- Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 11:13 pm
- Location: Guffey, Colorado, USA
- Contact:
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Nearly all of the ejected material either fell back to the Earth or collapsed into the Moon. Very little achieved escape velocity from the Earth-Moon system.Mooner wrote:My first question is; would material 'expelled' from early-history Earth automatically be pulled back into an Earth orbit at a certain distance from the Earth proportionate to it's mass?
No way of knowing, and since the collision pretty much melted the entire surface, after which the Earth kind of reformed, the question itself may not mean much.And a second question; from where exactly on Earth was this massive chunk of Earth expelled?
Chris
*****************************************
Chris L Peterson
Cloudbait Observatory
https://www.cloudbait.com
*****************************************
Chris L Peterson
Cloudbait Observatory
https://www.cloudbait.com
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Same video, different music: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T6CMvSKsHBopetsie wrote:is there another place than youtube to view the link behind the words "impacted the earth"? Youtube will not show that in germany due to ownership issues regarding the music![]()
Thanks in advance,
Peter
The sequence was lifted from a Discovery Channel special, but I've been unable to find the episode.
Know the quiet place within your heart and touch the rainbow of possibility; be
alive to the gentle breeze of communication, and please stop being such a jerk. — Garrison Keillor
alive to the gentle breeze of communication, and please stop being such a jerk. — Garrison Keillor
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
Thanks Chris for the rational explanation.
One follow-up question, would such a massive ejection of Earth material send one super-chunk-sized Moon material into an Earth-Moon gravitational system in relatively quick fashion (with minor fragments ultimately falling back to Earth), or would there more likely have been multiple larger chunks of material ejected from Earth in addition to many more smaller chunks expelled, which gradually over many years would have formed at various distances from the Earth - themselves eventually lumping together to form a single big moon? I'm just trying to wrap my head around the likely physics behind the actual process, as the video starts from an already-formed starting point. Thanks for any reply.
One follow-up question, would such a massive ejection of Earth material send one super-chunk-sized Moon material into an Earth-Moon gravitational system in relatively quick fashion (with minor fragments ultimately falling back to Earth), or would there more likely have been multiple larger chunks of material ejected from Earth in addition to many more smaller chunks expelled, which gradually over many years would have formed at various distances from the Earth - themselves eventually lumping together to form a single big moon? I'm just trying to wrap my head around the likely physics behind the actual process, as the video starts from an already-formed starting point. Thanks for any reply.
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
I wouldn't say a "chunk" was knocked out exactly.
I don't kow how factual the video is, but it shows an decent illustration of how the formation works. I think.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2sr-MriOCzw
I suggest turning the volume down too.![Smile :)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
I don't kow how factual the video is, but it shows an decent illustration of how the formation works. I think.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2sr-MriOCzw
I suggest turning the volume down too.
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
Re: APOD: Evolution of the Moon (2012 Mar 20)
I found this with Pink Floyd's "The Great Gig In The Sky" at 5min.com but thought I found the wrong one. This can't have too much to do with the formation of the moon (blue planet with oceans, cooled continents, even cities more than 4 gigayears agobystander wrote:Same video, different music: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T6CMvSKsHBo
![Shocked :shock:](./images/smilies/icon_eek.gif)
Thank you very much!
in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gadus ... PG">cod</a> we trust