by neufer » Fri Jan 29, 2021 9:33 pm
Chris Peterson wrote: ↑Fri Jan 29, 2021 2:34 am
DL MARTIN wrote: ↑Thu Jan 28, 2021 8:29 pm
What concerns me is that the idea that what we are perceiving is simply away rather than also ago seems to ignore change at the source. Its as if the Sun doesn't change during the intervening eight minutes of light travel. Yet we seem to deny this reality when referring to galaxies.
Because it is irrelevant. Indeed, the framework of special relativity is based on the idea that an event occurs when it is
observed (technically,
observable). We genuinely see the galaxy as it
is, in almost every way that matters. There is no meaningful "now" that extends to the entire universe. Every location has its own "now".
In
GENERAL relativity there is, indeed, a meaningful "
now" that extends to the entire universe: "
Now" is the time period when the Cosmic Microwave Background is at ~2.725 K (or roughly 13.8 billion years after the Big Bang).
However, we have
no reason to believe that the set of galaxies within about 3 billion light years of us are at all
unrepresentative of the galaxies which currently exist "
now". Hence, the
only real scientific purpose of knowing the distance to such "nearby" galaxies is:
- 1) to determine the current expansion rate of the Universe
2) to determine the size of the galaxy
3) to determine the color of the galaxy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe wrote:
<<The earliest stages of the universe's existence are estimated as taking place 13.8 billion years ago. After about 370,000 years, the universe finally becomes cool enough for neutral atoms to form ("recombination"), and as a result it also became transparent for the first time. The newly formed atoms—mainly hydrogen and helium with traces of lithium—quickly reach their lowest energy state (ground state) by releasing photons ("photon decoupling"), and these photons can still be detected today as the cosmic microwave background (CMB). This is currently the oldest observation we have of the universe.
After recombination and decoupling, the universe was transparent but the clouds of hydrogen only collapsed very slowly to form stars and galaxies, so there were no new sources of light. The only photons (electromagnetic radiation, or "light") in the universe were those released during decoupling (visible today as the cosmic microwave background) and 21 cm radio emissions occasionally emitted by hydrogen atoms. The decoupled photons would have filled the universe with a brilliant pale orange glow at first, gradually redshifting to non-visible wavelengths after about 3 million years, leaving it without visible light. This period is known as the cosmic Dark Ages.
Between about 10 and 17 million years the universe's average temperature was suitable for liquid water 273–373 K (0–100 °C) and there has been speculation whether rocky planets or indeed life could have arisen briefly, since statistically a tiny part of the universe could have had different conditions from the rest as a result of a very unlikely statistical fluctuation, and gained warmth from the universe as a whole.
At some point around 200 to 500 million years, the earliest generations of stars and galaxies form (exact timings are still being researched), and early large structures gradually emerge, drawn to the foam-like dark matter filaments which have already begun to draw together throughout the universe. The earliest generations of stars have not yet been observed astronomically. They may have been huge (100-300 solar masses) and non-metallic, with very short lifetimes compared to most stars we see today, so they commonly finish burning their hydrogen fuel and explode as highly energetic pair-instability supernovae after mere millions of years. Other theories suggest that they may have included small stars, some perhaps still burning today. In either case, these early generations of supernovae created most of the everyday elements we see around us today, and seeded the universe with them.
Galaxy clusters and superclusters emerge over time. At some point, high energy photons from the earliest stars, dwarf galaxies and perhaps quasars leads to a period of reionization that commences gradually between about 250-500 million years, is complete by about 700-900 million years, and diminishes by about 1 billion years (exact timings still being researched). The universe gradually transitioned into the universe we see around us today, and the Dark Ages only fully came to an end at about 1 billion years.
From 1 billion years, and for about 12.8 billion years, the universe has looked much as it does today. It will continue to appear very similar for many billions of years into the future. The thin disk of our galaxy began to form at about 5 billion years (8.8 Gya), and the Solar System formed at about 9.2 billion years (4.6 Gya), with the earliest traces of life on Earth emerging by about 10.3 billion years (3.5 Gya).
From about 9.8 billion years of cosmic time, the slowing expansion of space gradually begins to accelerate under the influence of dark energy, which may be a scalar field throughout our universe.>>
[quote="Chris Peterson" post_id=310322 time=1611887682 user_id=117706]
[quote="DL MARTIN" post_id=310312 time=1611865752]
What concerns me is that the idea that what we are perceiving is simply away rather than also ago seems to ignore change at the source. Its as if the Sun doesn't change during the intervening eight minutes of light travel. Yet we seem to deny this reality when referring to galaxies.[/quote]
Because it is irrelevant. Indeed, the framework of special relativity is based on the idea that an event occurs when it is [i]observed [/i](technically, [i]observable[/i]). We genuinely see the galaxy as it [i]is[/i], in almost every way that matters. There is no meaningful "now" that extends to the entire universe. Every location has its own "now".[/quote]
In [b][u][color=#0000FF]GENERAL[/color][/u][/b] relativity there is, indeed, a meaningful "[b][u][color=#0000FF]now[/color][/u][/b]" that extends to the entire universe: "[b][u][color=#0000FF]Now[/color][/u][/b]" is the time period when the Cosmic Microwave Background is at ~2.725 K (or roughly 13.8 billion years after the Big Bang).
However, we have [b][u][color=#0000FF]no[/color][/u][/b] reason to believe that the set of galaxies within about 3 billion light years of us are at all [b][u][color=#0000FF]unrepresentative[/color][/u][/b] of the galaxies which currently exist "[b][u][color=#0000FF]now[/color][/u][/b]". Hence, the [b][u][color=#FF0000]only[/color][/u][/b] real scientific purpose of knowing the distance to such "nearby" galaxies is:
[list]1) to determine the current expansion rate of the Universe
2) to determine the size of the galaxy
3) to determine the color of the galaxy.[/list]
[quote=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe]
[float=left][img3=GN-z11 is currently the oldest and most distant known galaxy in the observable universe. GN-z11 has a spectroscopic redshift of z = 11.09, which corresponds to a proper distance of approximately 32 billion light-years. Compared with the Milky Way galaxy, GN-z11 is 1⁄25 of the size, has 1% of the mass, and was forming new stars approximately twenty times as fast. With a stellar age estimated at 40 million years, it appears the galaxy formed its stars relatively rapidly. The fact that a galaxy so massive existed so soon after the first stars started to form is a challenge to some current theoretical models of the formation of galaxies.]https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/da/GNz11-FarthestGalaxyObservedByTheHST-20160303.jpg[/img3][/float]
<<The earliest stages of the universe's existence are estimated as taking place 13.8 billion years ago. After about 370,000 years, the universe finally becomes cool enough for neutral atoms to form ("recombination"), and as a result it also became transparent for the first time. The newly formed atoms—mainly hydrogen and helium with traces of lithium—quickly reach their lowest energy state (ground state) by releasing photons ("photon decoupling"), and these photons can still be detected today as the cosmic microwave background (CMB). This is currently the oldest observation we have of the universe.
After recombination and decoupling, the universe was transparent but the clouds of hydrogen only collapsed very slowly to form stars and galaxies, so there were no new sources of light. The only photons (electromagnetic radiation, or "light") in the universe were those released during decoupling (visible today as the cosmic microwave background) and 21 cm radio emissions occasionally emitted by hydrogen atoms. The decoupled photons would have filled the universe with a brilliant pale orange glow at first, gradually redshifting to non-visible wavelengths after about 3 million years, leaving it without visible light. This period is known as the cosmic Dark Ages.
Between about 10 and 17 million years the universe's average temperature was suitable for liquid water 273–373 K (0–100 °C) and there has been speculation whether rocky planets or indeed life could have arisen briefly, since statistically a tiny part of the universe could have had different conditions from the rest as a result of a very unlikely statistical fluctuation, and gained warmth from the universe as a whole.
At some point around 200 to 500 million years, the earliest generations of stars and galaxies form (exact timings are still being researched), and early large structures gradually emerge, drawn to the foam-like dark matter filaments which have already begun to draw together throughout the universe. The earliest generations of stars have not yet been observed astronomically. They may have been huge (100-300 solar masses) and non-metallic, with very short lifetimes compared to most stars we see today, so they commonly finish burning their hydrogen fuel and explode as highly energetic pair-instability supernovae after mere millions of years. Other theories suggest that they may have included small stars, some perhaps still burning today. In either case, these early generations of supernovae created most of the everyday elements we see around us today, and seeded the universe with them.
Galaxy clusters and superclusters emerge over time. At some point, high energy photons from the earliest stars, dwarf galaxies and perhaps quasars leads to a period of reionization that commences gradually between about 250-500 million years, is complete by about 700-900 million years, and diminishes by about 1 billion years (exact timings still being researched). The universe gradually transitioned into the universe we see around us today, and the Dark Ages only fully came to an end at about 1 billion years.
[b][u][color=#FF0000]From 1 billion years, and for about 12.8 billion years, the universe has looked much as it does today.[/color][/u][/b] It will continue to appear very similar for many billions of years into the future. The thin disk of our galaxy began to form at about 5 billion years (8.8 Gya), and the Solar System formed at about 9.2 billion years (4.6 Gya), with the earliest traces of life on Earth emerging by about 10.3 billion years (3.5 Gya).
From about 9.8 billion years of cosmic time, the slowing expansion of space gradually begins to accelerate under the influence of dark energy, which may be a scalar field throughout our universe.>>[/quote]