APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) :ssmile: :( :o :shock: :? 8-) :lol2: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen:
View more smilies

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by neufer » Mon Jan 06, 2020 12:01 am

Chris Peterson wrote: Sun Jan 05, 2020 9:11 pm
Ann wrote: Sun Jan 05, 2020 9:07 pm
I just struck me... the name Betelgeuse. The name itself tells us that Betelgeuse must be the Beta star of Orion, doesn't' it?
Well, it doesn't mean that. But it's a nice mnemonic.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betelgeuse#Nomenclature wrote:
<<α Orionis (Latinised to Alpha Orionis) is the star's designation given by Johann Bayer in 1603. The traditional name Betelgeuse is derived from the Arabic إبط الجوزاء Ibṭ al-Jauzā’, meaning "the armpit of Orion.". The WGSN's first bulletin of July 2016 included a table of the first two batches of names approved by the WGSN, which included Betelgeuse for this star. It is now so entered in the IAU Catalog of Star Names.

In the popular science fiction series The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams, Ford Prefect was from "a small planet somewhere in the vicinity of Betelgeuse." Humbert Wolfe wrote a poem about Betelgeuse, which was set to music by Gustav Holst.

Click to play embedded YouTube video.
  • On Betelgeuse
    the gold leaves hang in golden aisles
    for twice a hundred million miles,
    and twice a hundred million years
    they golden hang and nothing stirs,
    on Betelgeuse.

    Space is a wind that does
    not blow on Betelgeuse,
    and time - oh time - is a bird,
    whose wings have never stirred
    the golden avenues of leaves
    on Betelgeuse.

    On Betelgeuse
    there is nothing that joys or grieves
    the unstirred multitude of leaves,
    nor ghost of evil or good haunts
    the gold multitude
    on Betelgeuse.

    And birth they do not use
    nor death on Betelgeuse,
    and the God, of whom we are
    infinite dust, is there
    a single leaf of those
    gold leaves on Betelgeuse.
    >>>>

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Chris Peterson » Sun Jan 05, 2020 9:11 pm

Ann wrote: Sun Jan 05, 2020 9:07 pm I just struck me... the name Betelgeuse. The name itself tells us that Betelgeuse must be the Beta star of Orion, doesn't' it?
Well, it doesn't mean that. But it's a nice mnemonic.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Ann » Sun Jan 05, 2020 9:07 pm

I just struck me... the name Betelgeuse. The name itself tells us that Betelgeuse must be the Beta star of Orion, doesn't' it?

Ann

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by neufer » Sun Jan 05, 2020 6:48 pm

Click to play embedded YouTube video.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Ann » Sun Jan 05, 2020 6:02 am

TheZuke! wrote: Sun Jan 05, 2020 3:41 am
neufer wrote: Sat Jan 04, 2020 2:38 pm
After rethinking...

The Cygnus Loop is ~130 ly in diameter at an age of around 21,000 years.
Simeis 147 is ~160 ly in diameter at an age of around 40,000 years.

Once SNRs are this large they have already swept up at least a thousand solar masses of interstellar medium.

Every time they double their size after that their mass becomes 8 times larger and so they must then expand 8 times slower.

momentum = MV = R3dR/dt = C1

R4 = C2 t

R = C3 t1/4

Hence, the expansion (after ~200 ly in diameter) soon drops below a sound velocity of ~5 km/s and the shock fronts all dissipate.

(Note: Betelgeuse is already moving away at ~21 km/s so its shock front stops approaching us before dissipating.)
Wow!
Thanks!

Hey, Art, I'm impressed, too. And I could fully understand your reasoning! :D

On a different note, last night the sky was finally clear enough for me to see Betelgeuse and the entire Orion constellation. Yes, Orion sure looks strange with Betelgeuse so faint! The sky was misty and the seeing was quite poor, and when Betelgeuse was low and Aldebaran was higher, Aldebaran blazed like an orange traffic light of the sky, while Betelgeuse looked wan. Betelgeuse looked equal in brightness to Bellatrix, the "other shoulder" of Orion. Rigel looked "blatant" as Orion's left foot.

Ann

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by TheZuke! » Sun Jan 05, 2020 3:41 am

neufer wrote: Sat Jan 04, 2020 2:38 pm
After rethinking...

The Cygnus Loop is ~130 ly in diameter at an age of around 21,000 years.
Simeis 147 is ~160 ly in diameter at an age of around 40,000 years.

Once SNRs are this large they have already swept up at least a thousand solar masses of interstellar medium.

Every time they double their size after that their mass becomes 8 times larger and so they must then expand 8 times slower.

momentum = MV = R3dR/dt = C1

R4 = C2 t

R = C3 t1/4

Hence, the expansion (after ~200 ly in diameter) soon drops below a sound velocity of ~5 km/s and the shock fronts all dissipate.

(Note: Betelgeuse is already moving away at ~21 km/s so its shock front stops approaching us before dissipating.)
Wow!
Thanks!

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by neufer » Sat Jan 04, 2020 2:38 pm

neufer wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 11:53 pm
Chris Peterson wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:50 pm
TheZuke! wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:39 pm
The resident "know it all" in my workplace has said that when Betelgeuse explodes, its cloud will eventually engulf our solar system reducing visible stars to about one third.

Has anyone else heard/read of that?
Not even close. Even assuming that the material isn't dissipated unevenly by other forces, imagine the material of a star spread into a volume of about a billion cubic light years. That's a very hard vacuum.
The issue isn't so much with the initial blasted material as with all the intervening material that is swept up into a relatively thin shock front.

I estimate that it might reach us in about 2 million years (or around the time the Vela Supernova Remnant reaches us). During the limited time we are within a shock front there may be some noticeable obscuration of stars that also lie along the same shock front...especially if the UV from such stars results in local fluorescence.
After rethinking...

The Cygnus Loop is ~130 ly in diameter at an age of around 21,000 years.
Simeis 147 is ~160 ly in diameter at an age of around 40,000 years.

Once SNRs are this large they have already swept up at least a thousand solar masses of interstellar medium.

Every time they double their size after that their mass becomes 8 times larger and so they must then expand 8 times slower.

momentum = MV = R3dR/dt = C1

R4 = C2 t

R = C3 t1/4

Hence, the expansion (after ~200 ly in diameter) soon drops below a sound velocity of ~5 km/s and the shock fronts all dissipate.

(Note: Betelgeuse is already moving away at ~21 km/s so its shock front stops approaching us before dissipating.)

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Ann » Sat Jan 04, 2020 6:04 am

neufer wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 11:53 pm
Chris Peterson wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:50 pm
TheZuke! wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:39 pm
The resident "know it all" in my workplace has said that when Betelgeuse explodes, its cloud will eventually engulf our solar system reducing visible stars to about one third.

Has anyone else heard/read of that?
Not even close. Even assuming that the material isn't dissipated unevenly by other forces, imagine the material of a star spread into a volume of about a billion cubic light years. That's a very hard vacuum.
The issue isn't so much with the initial blasted material as with all the intervening material that is swept up into a relatively thin shock front.

I estimate that it might reach us in about 2 million years (or around the time the Vela Supernova Remnant reaches us). During the limited time we are within a shock front there may be some noticeable obscuration of stars that also lie along the same shock front...especially if the UV from such stars results in local fluorescence.
Vela supernova remnant. Robert Gendler, Roberto Colombari, Digitized Sky Survey.
This is the Vela supernova remnant. You can see thin blue-green lines of glowing OIII, and some thin pink lines of ionized hydrogen.

How opaque are this fronts? My amateur impression is that they wouldn't cause much obscuration in the sky.

Ann

Edit: I love it when Art and Chris start arguing about general and special relativity.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by neufer » Fri Jan 03, 2020 11:53 pm

Chris Peterson wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:50 pm
TheZuke! wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:39 pm
The resident "know it all" in my workplace has said that when Betelgeuse explodes, its cloud will eventually engulf our solar system reducing visible stars to about one third.

Has anyone else heard/read of that?
Not even close. Even assuming that the material isn't dissipated unevenly by other forces, imagine the material of a star spread into a volume of about a billion cubic light years. That's a very hard vacuum.
The issue isn't so much with the initial blasted material as with all the intervening material that is swept up into a relatively thin shock front.

I estimate that it might reach us in about 2 million years (or around the time the Vela Supernova Remnant reaches us). During the limited time we are within a shock front there may be some noticeable obscuration of stars that also lie along the same shock front...especially if the UV from such stars results in local fluorescence.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by geckzilla » Fri Jan 03, 2020 11:47 pm

Chris Peterson wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:50 pm
TheZuke! wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:39 pm The resident "know it all" in my workplace has said that when Betelgeuse explodes, its cloud will eventually engulf our solar system reducing visible stars to about one third.

Has anyone else heard/read of that?
Not even close. Even assuming that the material isn't dissipated unevenly by other forces, imagine the material of a star spread into a volume of about a billion cubic light years. That's a very hard vacuum.
Plus, like... wouldn't it have already happened? Wouldn't we be trapped in dust-obscured darkness by now if every supernova within a few hundred light years darkened the stars? This know-it-all doesn't know enough to select sources that aren't wildly fictitious.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Chris Peterson » Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:50 pm

TheZuke! wrote: Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:39 pm The resident "know it all" in my workplace has said that when Betelgeuse explodes, its cloud will eventually engulf our solar system reducing visible stars to about one third.

Has anyone else heard/read of that?
Not even close. Even assuming that the material isn't dissipated unevenly by other forces, imagine the material of a star spread into a volume of about a billion cubic light years. That's a very hard vacuum.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by TheZuke! » Fri Jan 03, 2020 10:39 pm

The resident "know it all" in my workplace has said that when Betelgeuse explodes, its cloud will eventually engulf our solar system reducing visible stars to about one third.

Has anyone else heard/read of that?

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Chris Peterson » Thu Jan 02, 2020 4:40 pm

neufer wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 4:36 pm (General relativity allows us to arbitrarily set space-time coordinates.)
I think that's more accurately seen as a feature of special relativity.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by neufer » Thu Jan 02, 2020 4:36 pm

Fred the Cat wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 4:07 pm
Chris Peterson wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 2:43 pm
Pannick wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 8:41 am
But if it happened 699 years and 6 months ago we would only know about this year - wouldn't we? Help!
The event is defined by its observation. It happens when the first radiation reaches us. That's when we'll know about it. That will be t=0.
Yes, time equal to zero should be quite a celestial event. :thumb_up:
For all sorts of pragmatic reasons it is
useful in almost all cases to define
t=0 as lying along our own past light cone.

(General relativity allows us to arbitrarily set space-time coordinates.)

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Fred the Cat » Thu Jan 02, 2020 4:07 pm

Yes, time equal to zero should be quite a celestial event. :thumb_up:

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by neufer » Thu Jan 02, 2020 3:29 pm

"Begirt with many a blazing star" :?:

https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap200102.html
https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap120119.html

More like begirt with many a bare branch!

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by neufer » Thu Jan 02, 2020 3:22 pm

Ann wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 6:39 am
BDanielMayfield wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 6:06 am
Betelgeuse is also recognized as a nearby red supergiant star that will end its life in a core collapse supernova explosion sometime in the next 1,000 years, though that cosmic cataclysm will take place a safe 700 light-years or so from our fair planet.
Is that 1,000 years figure a mistake? Yesterday's discussion indicated sometime in the next 100,000 years.
The 1,000 years figure is definitely a mistake! Yes, Betelgeuse could go in 1,000 years. Heck, it could go tomorrow, for all we know.

But it might just as easily last for another 100,000 years, or maybe even longer. After all, it is the condition of the core of Betelgeuse that determines when it will explode. And the core of any star is hidden from us behind thick opaque gases. The reason why the gases are opaque is that the photons from the core keep scattering off electrons and atomic nuclei on their way to the surface of the star.
  • You are right about the 1,000 years figure, Ann.

    However, red giants don't have much of a radiative zone
    and core/burning shell changes may not take 171,000 years to signal us.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_zone wrote:
<<A radiation zone, or radiative region is a layer of a star's interior where energy is primarily transported toward the exterior by means of radiative diffusion and thermal conduction, rather than by convection. Energy travels through the radiation zone in the form of electromagnetic radiation as photons. Matter in a radiation zone is so dense that photons can travel only a short distance before they are absorbed or scattered by another particle, gradually shifting to longer wavelength as they do so. For this reason, it takes an average of 171,000 years for gamma rays from the core of the Sun to leave the radiation zone. Over this range, the temperature of the plasma drops from 15 million K near the core down to 1.5 million K at the base of the convection zone.>>
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convection_zone wrote:
<<A convection zone, convective zone or convective region of a star is a layer which is unstable to convection. Energy is primarily or partially transported by convection in such a region. In a radiation zone, energy is transported by radiation and conduction.

Stellar convection consists of mass movement of plasma within the star which usually forms a circular convection current with the heated plasma ascending and the cooled plasma descending.

If the temperature gradient is steep enough (i. e. the temperature changes rapidly with distance from the center of the star), or if the gas has a very high heat capacity (i. e. its temperature changes relatively slowly as it expands) then the rising parcel of gas will remain warmer and less dense than its new surroundings even after expanding and cooling. Its buoyancy will then cause it to continue to rise. The region of the star in which this happens is the convection zone.

In the most massive stars, the convection zone may reach all the way from the core to the surface. In red giant stars, and particularly during the asymptotic giant branch phase, the surface convection zone varies in depth during the phases of shell burning. This causes dredge-up events, short-lived very deep convection zones that transport fusion products to the surface of the star.>>

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Chris Peterson » Thu Jan 02, 2020 2:43 pm

Pannick wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 8:41 am But if it happened 699 years and 6 months ago we would only know about this year - wouldn't we? Help!
The event is defined by its observation. It happens when the first radiation reaches us. That's when we'll know about it. That will be t=0.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Astronymus » Thu Jan 02, 2020 1:40 pm

Pannick wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 8:41 am But if it happened 699 years and 6 months ago we would only know about this year - wouldn't we? Help!
Roughly around that, yes. We get a few hours warning though. Neutrinos will escape the star in peak numbers before any light or shockwave can.

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by orin stepanek » Thu Jan 02, 2020 11:38 am

I love the Orion Constellation & it's beauty in the night sky! :yes:

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by BDanielMayfield » Thu Jan 02, 2020 10:15 am

BDanielMayfield wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 9:38 am
BDanielMayfield wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 8:58 am Being normally among the brighter stars, Betelgeuse would be too bright for the Gaia mission to study. But if it fades enough (and for long enough) maybe Gaia can nail down its distance and motion :!:
After looking up info on Gaia I now see that it doesn't have the brightness limitation that I thought it did, for it can collect data on all stars down to Mag 20. I must have gotten this mission confused with another.
However, I now find that Gaia did originally have an overly bright star limitation, but work-arounds are expected to solve this limitation.
Although the European Space Agency's current Gaia mission was not expected to produce good results for stars brighter than the approximately V=6 saturation limit of the mission's instruments,[86] actual operation has shown good performance on objects to about magnitude +3. Forced observations of brighter stars mean that final results should be available for all bright stars and a parallax for Betelgeuse will be published an order of magnitude more accurate than currently available.[87]

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by BDanielMayfield » Thu Jan 02, 2020 9:38 am

BDanielMayfield wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 8:58 am Being normally among the brighter stars, Betelgeuse would be too bright for the Gaia mission to study. But if it fades enough (and for long enough) maybe Gaia can nail down its distance and motion :!:
After looking up info on Gaia I now see that it doesn't have the brightness limitation that I thought it did, for it can collect data on all stars down to Mag 20. I must have gotten this mission confused with another.

Bruce

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by BDanielMayfield » Thu Jan 02, 2020 8:58 am

Ann wrote:The 1,000 years figure is definitely a mistake!
I thought so too, but didn't want to be so blunt about it.:o But I also held out a small hope that maybe it was true somehow. Darn.

Being normally among the brighter stars, Betelgeuse would be too bright for the Gaia mission to study. But if it fades enough (and for long enough) maybe Gaia can nail down its distance and motion :!:

Bruce

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Pannick » Thu Jan 02, 2020 8:41 am

But if it happened 699 years and 6 months ago we would only know about this year - wouldn't we? Help!

Re: APOD: The Fainting of Betelgeuse (2020 Jan 02)

by Ann » Thu Jan 02, 2020 6:39 am

BDanielMayfield wrote: Thu Jan 02, 2020 6:06 am
Betelgeuse is also recognized as a nearby red supergiant star that will end its life in a core collapse supernova explosion sometime in the next 1,000 years, though that cosmic cataclysm will take place a safe 700 light-years or so from our fair planet.
Is that 1,000 years figure a mistake? Yesterday's discussion indicated sometime in the next 100,000 years.
Nuclear reactions in the Sun's core produce light and other types of radiation.
As light photons leave the core, they run into electrons and atomic nuclei,
scattering off each one. These interactions cause photons to take,
on average, 200,000 years to move from the Sun's core to its surface.
Illustration: Roen Kelly, Astronomy Magazine.
The 1,000 years figure is definitely a mistake! Yes, Betelgeuse could go in 1,000 years. Heck, it could go tomorrow, for all we know.

But it might just as easily last for another 100,000 years, or maybe even longer. After all, it is the condition of the core of Betelgeuse that determines when it will explode. And the core of any star is hidden from us behind thick opaque gases. The reason why the gases are opaque is that the photons from the core keep scattering off electrons and atomic nuclei on their way to the surface of the star.

Ann

Top