by Ann » Fri Apr 26, 2019 5:23 pm
NCTom wrote: ↑Fri Apr 26, 2019 12:02 pm
Thanks, Ann, for the explanation. You definitely keep the science from getting boring!
Thanks a lot, Tom!
I was going to talk about several of the objects in the Crux-Centaurus-Carina region, but researching and writing so much will drive me crazy. And many of the rest of you will get really tired of me, probably.
So I'll write about just one more object in today's APOD. A blue star, wouldn't you know it!
Cluster IC 2602 and its luminary Theta Carinae.
Photo: Fred Espenak.
Yes, but this blue star is special. Not because it is the brightest of the blue stars in the heavens - it isn't even an O-type star, for goodness sake - but because it is far too young for its cluster! It really is!!!
For you, Dino, Theta Carina wasn't there.
Here's the deal. Theta Carina is a B0 spectral type star (or perhaps B0.5V), which is about as hot and bright as a normal hydrogen-fusing star can get without being an O-star. That means That Theta Carina must be massive, which in turn means it is going to use up its core hydrogen very fast, like all massive stars do. And since it is still happily fusing away hydrogen in its core, it must be young. Only about four times as old as humanity, or four million years old,
according to Wikipedia. The dinosaurs never got to see it.
So Theta Carina is only four million years old. Yes, but the cluster it is sitting in is much older!
Wikipedia wrote:
IC 2602 is likely about the same age as the open cluster IC 2391,[4] which has a lithium depletion boundary age of
50 million years old,[5] though the accepted age from its HR-Diagram is about
13.7 million years.
Wikipedia wrote:
Theta Carinae is a single-lined spectroscopic binary with a 2.2 day period
The estimated age of the pair is
4 million years
and it appears much younger than the surrounding IC 2602 cluster.
Jim Kaler wrote:
Theta Car is in fact TOO bright. Clusters, born with an intact mass sequence of hydrogen-burners, die from the top down, high mass stars going first. The top of IC 2602's is considerably less massive than Theta. From the maximum general mass remaining,
the cluster's age is set at 34 million years.
Yet Theta is anomalously dated to be just a couple million years old.
Matter transfer in an Algol system. Copyright: MPL 3D
What's going on here? Theta Carina is like a happy toddler attending a class of bored teenagers!
The solution to the conundrum is that Theta Carina is a blue straggler, a star that has gained youth and power by stealing matter from others! Theta would be the perfect poster child for such stars, if well-known Algol in Perseus hadn't already grabbed that glory for itself. Except that Algol isn't even known as a blue straggler star, but of course it is one!
Jim Kaler wrote:
Algol is famed first as a prototype of the class of eclipsing double stars, of which thousands are known. (...) But Algol is equally famed for the "Algol paradox." The higher the mass of a star, the shorter its lifetime, as its fuel is used so much faster. The companion to Algol is the dying giant star. Yet carrying but 0.81 solar masses, it is the LESS massive of the two (the B star weighing in at 3.7 solar).
The only explanation is that the dim companion has lost a great deal of mass. The two stars are so close together, separated by only five percent the distance between the Earth and the Sun, that the brighter smaller star produces tides in the larger one. Matter then flows in from the large one (at a rate of around two hundred- millionths of a solar mass per year) to the small bright one, the effect directly observed through the stellar spectrum as the K giant is being stripped nearly to its core.
Theta Carina is a blue straggler like Algol, and it has stolen matter from a close companion like the primary star of Algol.
Wikipedia wrote about Theta Carina:
In this spectroscopic system, the primary star is probably a blue straggler, which is an unusual type of star created by merging or the interaction between two or more stars. The source of the mass transfer is likely to be the less massive secondary companion, and what is now is the primary star was probably originally the less massive component. The estimated age of the pair is 4 million years,[7] and it appears much younger than the surrounding IC 2602 cluster.[6]
The primary star is about 15 solar masses (M☉) and five solar radii (R☉).[6] Theta Carinae has an intensely hot outer radiating envelope with an effective surface temperature of 31,000 K.[9] Once the primary reaches around 11 million years old, the star will expand and will begin to transferring its outer surface mass back to its companion. Little is known about the companion star, but it is likely an F-type star with a luminosity less than 1% of the primary.
Photo: Denis Omelchenko/Shutterstock
So there you have it. Theta Carina is in all probability just as old as the other stars of the IC 2602 cluster. But Theta has stolen a lot of mass from its hapless companion, and all that fresh hydrogen that has been dumped on Theta acts as a youth elixir that allows this brash star to pose as an energetic baby among slightly tired teenagers.
And next time you read about an
impossibly massive and hot star, ask yourself if this star couldn't be a blue straggler.
Ann
[quote=NCTom post_id=291763 time=1556280120]
Thanks, Ann, for the explanation. You definitely keep the science from getting boring!
[/quote]
Thanks a lot, Tom! :D
I was going to talk about several of the objects in the Crux-Centaurus-Carina region, but researching and writing so much will drive me crazy. And many of the rest of you will get really tired of me, probably.
So I'll write about just one more object in today's APOD. A blue star, wouldn't you know it! :wink:
[float=left][img2]http://astropixels.com/openclusters/images/IC2602-01w.jpg[/img2][c][size=85]Cluster IC 2602 and its luminary Theta Carinae.
Photo: Fred Espenak.[/size][/c][/float]
Yes, but this blue star is special. Not because it is the brightest of the blue stars in the heavens - it isn't even an O-type star, for goodness sake - but because it is far too young for its cluster! It really is!!!
[float=right][img2]https://i.pinimg.com/originals/1d/3e/58/1d3e58acd48142aef2fba9d1271c7d3d.jpg[/img2][c][size=85]For you, Dino, Theta Carina wasn't there.[/size][/c][/float]
Here's the deal. Theta Carina is a B0 spectral type star (or perhaps B0.5V), which is about as hot and bright as a normal hydrogen-fusing star can get without being an O-star. That means That Theta Carina must be massive, which in turn means it is going to use up its core hydrogen very fast, like all massive stars do. And since it is still happily fusing away hydrogen in its core, it must be young. Only about four times as old as humanity, or four million years old, [url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theta_Carinae]according to Wikipedia[/url]. The dinosaurs never got to see it.
So Theta Carina is only four million years old. Yes, but the cluster it is sitting in is much older!
[quote][url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IC_2602]Wikipedia[/url] wrote:
IC 2602 is likely about the same age as the open cluster IC 2391,[4] which has a lithium depletion boundary age of [b][color=#008000]50 million years old[/color][/b],[5] though the accepted age from its HR-Diagram is about [b][color=#0080BF]13.7 million years[/color][/b].[/quote]
[quote][url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theta_Carinae]Wikipedia[/url] wrote:
Theta Carinae is a single-lined spectroscopic binary with a 2.2 day period
The estimated age of the pair is [b][color=#0080FF]4 million years[/color][/b]
and it appears much younger than the surrounding IC 2602 cluster.[/quote]
[quote][url=http://stars.astro.illinois.edu/sow/thetacar.html]Jim Kaler[/url] wrote:
Theta Car is in fact TOO bright. Clusters, born with an intact mass sequence of hydrogen-burners, die from the top down, high mass stars going first. The top of IC 2602's is considerably less massive than Theta. From the maximum general mass remaining, [b][color=#008000]the cluster's age is set at 34 million years[/color][/b]. [b][color=#0080FF]Yet Theta is anomalously dated to be just a couple million years old[/color][/b].[/quote]
[float=right][img2]https://www.sott.net/image/s5/101388/full/demon_star1.jpg[/img2][c][size=85]Matter transfer in an Algol system. Copyright: MPL 3D[/size][/c][/float]What's going on here? Theta Carina is like a happy toddler attending a class of bored teenagers!
The solution to the conundrum is that Theta Carina is a blue straggler, a star that has gained youth and power by stealing matter from others! Theta would be the perfect poster child for such stars, if well-known Algol in Perseus hadn't already grabbed that glory for itself. Except that Algol isn't even known as a blue straggler star, but of course it is one!
[quote][url=http://stars.astro.illinois.edu/Sow/algol.html]Jim Kaler[/url] wrote:
Algol is famed first as a prototype of the class of eclipsing double stars, of which thousands are known. (...) But Algol is equally famed for the "Algol paradox." The higher the mass of a star, the shorter its lifetime, as its fuel is used so much faster. The companion to Algol is the dying giant star. Yet carrying but 0.81 solar masses, it is the LESS massive of the two (the B star weighing in at 3.7 solar).
The only explanation is that the dim companion has lost a great deal of mass. The two stars are so close together, separated by only five percent the distance between the Earth and the Sun, that the brighter smaller star produces tides in the larger one. Matter then flows in from the large one (at a rate of around two hundred- millionths of a solar mass per year) to the small bright one, the effect directly observed through the stellar spectrum as the K giant is being stripped nearly to its core.[/quote]
Theta Carina is a blue straggler like Algol, and it has stolen matter from a close companion like the primary star of Algol.
[quote][url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theta_Carinae]Wikipedia[/url] wrote about Theta Carina:
In this spectroscopic system, the primary star is probably a blue straggler, which is an unusual type of star created by merging or the interaction between two or more stars. The source of the mass transfer is likely to be the less massive secondary companion, and what is now is the primary star was probably originally the less massive component. The estimated age of the pair is 4 million years,[7] and it appears much younger than the surrounding IC 2602 cluster.[6]
The primary star is about 15 solar masses (M☉) and five solar radii (R☉).[6] Theta Carinae has an intensely hot outer radiating envelope with an effective surface temperature of 31,000 K.[9] Once the primary reaches around 11 million years old, the star will expand and will begin to transferring its outer surface mass back to its companion. Little is known about the companion star, but it is likely an F-type star with a luminosity less than 1% of the primary.[/quote]
[float=left][img2]https://i.cbc.ca/1.4410411.1511198470!/fileImage/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/16x9_780/toddler-playing.jpg[/img2][c][size=85]Photo: Denis Omelchenko/Shutterstock[/size][/c][/float]So there you have it. Theta Carina is in all probability just as old as the other stars of the IC 2602 cluster. But Theta has stolen a lot of mass from its hapless companion, and all that fresh hydrogen that has been dumped on Theta acts as a youth elixir that allows this brash star to pose as an energetic baby among slightly tired teenagers.
And next time you read about an [url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_massive_stars]impossibly massive and hot star[/url], ask yourself if this star couldn't be a blue straggler.
Ann