Hi! I'm a long time fan of APOD (I have a folder of nearly 6 years of pics!), but this is my first post on this forum.
I think I was inspired to post by all the recent hullabaloo over nomenclature at the IAU; likely a hot topic!
The APOD for 26/8/06 (which is a beautiful pic, by the way!) refers to NGC1300 as an 'island universe'. I am aware of the term; my dad has an encyclopaedia from the 1940's that has some wonderful hand-painted illustrations of 'island universes'.
Surely the term is an anachronism nowdays? After all, we don't refer to 'busses' as 'motor-charabancs', or 'cars' as 'horseless carriages' unless we are trying to be anachronistic, obscure or both!
If we can keep refering to galaxies as 'island universes', can we also please keep refering to Ceres and Juno as 'planets' as they were originally described?
I expect an IAU lynch mob to be on my doorstep in moments to re-educate me!
Cheers, and thanks to the APOD editors & contributors for years & years of daily art for my desktop!
Adrian
Hi! I'm a long time fan of APOD (I have a folder of nearly 6 years of pics!), but this is my first post on this forum.
I think I was inspired to post by all the recent hullabaloo over nomenclature at the IAU; likely a hot topic!
The APOD for 26/8/06 (which is a beautiful pic, by the way!) refers to NGC1300 as an 'island universe'. I am aware of the term; my dad has an encyclopaedia from the 1940's that has some wonderful hand-painted illustrations of 'island universes'.
Surely the term is an anachronism nowdays? After all, we don't refer to 'busses' as 'motor-charabancs', or 'cars' as 'horseless carriages' unless we are trying to be anachronistic, obscure or both! :D
If we can keep refering to galaxies as 'island universes', can we also please keep refering to Ceres and Juno as 'planets' as they were originally described?
I expect an IAU lynch mob to be on my doorstep in moments to re-educate me! :lol:
Cheers, and thanks to the APOD editors & contributors for years & years of daily art for my desktop!
Adrian