by Anthony Barreiro » Tue Jan 28, 2014 7:37 pm
Chris Peterson wrote:Cousin Ricky wrote:Is M83 really a barred spiral, or is it just a regular spiral whose arms are unusually straight near the center? In images of all other barred spirals I've seen, the bar structure is distinct from the arms, but this does not seem to be the case with M83.
Isn't any barred spiral just a spiral whose arms are unusually straight near the center?
Morphological classifications of galaxies seem to have at least as much to do with our human desire to have everything fit neatly into one and only one taxonomic box as with the shapes and dynamic processes of galaxies. There are real differences between, say, spiral and elliptical galaxies, but galaxies seem to exist along a morphological continuum (or several continua), with no clear, objective boundary between one type and another, and many intermediate cases. They're not like finches, where you can distinguish one species from another by observing breeding habits.
[quote="Chris Peterson"][quote="Cousin Ricky"]Is M83 really a barred spiral, or is it just a regular spiral whose arms are unusually straight near the center? In images of all other barred spirals I've seen, the bar structure is distinct from the arms, but this does not seem to be the case with M83.[/quote]
Isn't any barred spiral just a spiral whose arms are unusually straight near the center?[/quote]
Morphological classifications of galaxies seem to have at least as much to do with our human desire to have everything fit neatly into one and only one taxonomic box as with the shapes and dynamic processes of galaxies. There are real differences between, say, spiral and elliptical galaxies, but galaxies seem to exist along a morphological continuum (or several continua), with no clear, objective boundary between one type and another, and many intermediate cases. They're not like finches, where you can distinguish one species from another by observing breeding habits.