It's a great picture, but I'm a little disappointed in the caption.
http://www.eso.org/public/news/eso1320/ wrote:
Known to astronomers as a reflection nebula, this type of object usually appears blue because the scattering is more efficient for these shorter wavelengths of light [2].
Certainly, but the stars inside reflection nebulae are usually intrinsically blue, too. Any star that is hot enough to ionize a red emission nebula is itself intrinsically blue.
But it is unusual for emission and reflection nebulae to be so sharply separated, if they are powered by the same star(s).
The Trifid Nebula is an example of a nebula where the emission and reflection components are well separated, but the large blue reflection nebula is either powered by another star than the one that ionizes the emission nebula, or else this is actually an example of where dust scatters short-wave blue starlight far from the star, but doesn't scatter more nearby long-wave red Ha light.
The star that ionizes the red part of the Trifid Nebula is a hot young O-type star. Because the star is so young, there is still some dust in its vicinity, and the innermost region of the Trifid is faintly bluish from dust that reflects the stars' blue light. But the bluish inner reflection nebula merges smoothly with the red emission nebula outside it. This is very different from the appearance of NGC 6559.
Here is my interpretation of it. The blue stars inside the blue reflection nebula next to NGC 6559 are not hot enough to ionize the kind of emission nebula that surrounds the central star of the Trifid Nebula. The stars' blue light is scattered by the dust cloud that surrounds them, but their ultraviolet light is not powerful enough to ionize the hydrogen that is undoubtedly there in the blue reflection nebula.
Instead, the red emission nebula is a ridge, a piled-up ridge of hydrogen that is pummeled by stellar winds from two directions. The blue stars inside the blue reflection nebula undoubtedly produce a stellar wind that pushes the gas outside it outwards. But the same gas is feeling the stellar wind of the B-type blue star that can be seen in the lower left corner of the ESO picture.
Central IC 1805.
Photo: Keith Quattrocchi.
Another example of a ridge can be seen in the core of the Heart Nebula, IC 1805. However, there are several O-type stars in this nebula, and all of it is ionized by the hot stars. Nevertheless, there is a ridge in the center of it, where gas and dust is being pummeled by stellar winds from two directions.
That's why I think that NGC 6559 is a ridge of gas being "pushed" from two directions by B-type stars, which themselves are not hot enough to ionize an emission nebula around them.
Ann
It's a great picture, but I'm a little disappointed in the caption.
[quote]http://www.eso.org/public/news/eso1320/ wrote:
Known to astronomers as a reflection nebula, this type of object usually appears blue because the scattering is more efficient for these shorter wavelengths of light [2].[/quote]
Certainly, but the stars inside reflection nebulae are usually intrinsically blue, too. Any star that is hot enough to ionize a red emission nebula is itself intrinsically blue.
But it is unusual for emission and reflection nebulae to be so sharply separated, if they are powered by the same star(s). [url=http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/image/0907/m20_block_big.jpg]The Trifid Nebula[/url] is an example of a nebula where the emission and reflection components are well separated, but the large blue reflection nebula is either powered by another star than the one that ionizes the emission nebula, or else this is actually an example of where dust scatters short-wave blue starlight far from the star, but doesn't scatter more nearby long-wave red Ha light.
The star that ionizes the red part of the Trifid Nebula is a hot young O-type star. Because the star is so young, there is still some dust in its vicinity, and the innermost region of the Trifid is faintly bluish from dust that reflects the stars' blue light. But the bluish inner reflection nebula merges smoothly with the red emission nebula outside it. This is very different from the appearance of NGC 6559.
Here is my interpretation of it. The blue stars inside the blue reflection nebula next to NGC 6559 are not hot enough to ionize the kind of emission nebula that surrounds the central star of the Trifid Nebula. The stars' blue light is scattered by the dust cloud that surrounds them, but their ultraviolet light is not powerful enough to ionize the hydrogen that is undoubtedly there in the blue reflection nebula.
Instead, the red emission nebula is a ridge, a piled-up ridge of hydrogen that is pummeled by stellar winds from two directions. The blue stars inside the blue reflection nebula undoubtedly produce a stellar wind that pushes the gas outside it outwards. But the same gas is feeling the stellar wind of the B-type blue star that can be seen in the lower left corner of the ESO picture.
[float=left][img]http://sierra-remote.com/Astrophotography%20Page/Keith_Quattrocchi_ic1805_B.jpg[/img][c][size=85]Central IC 1805.
Photo: Keith Quattrocchi.[/size][/c][/float] Another example of a ridge can be seen in the core of the Heart Nebula, IC 1805. However, there are several O-type stars in this nebula, and all of it is ionized by the hot stars. Nevertheless, there is a ridge in the center of it, where gas and dust is being pummeled by stellar winds from two directions.
That's why I think that NGC 6559 is a ridge of gas being "pushed" from two directions by B-type stars, which themselves are not hot enough to ionize an emission nebula around them.
Ann