by Ann » Wed Jan 18, 2012 7:24 am
This is certainly a most impressive image. I can easily imagine that it is a treasure trove for professional astronomers.
For me, however, the image is beautiful, yet confusing. The picture tells me no story. Yes, I can understand that it shows me the presence of a lot of dust. Yes, I can understand that the dust has different temperatures and structures. But what do those temperatures and structures mean?
Yes, I can understand that redder gas is colder and greener gas is warmer. Yes, I can understand that cool - make that cold - dust is good for making stars. And yes, I can understand that dust that is warmer has probably already been affected by the heat and radiation of of hot stars.
But I can't see where in this image stars are being born. More frustratingly for me, I can think of no way to judge how massive the stars are that are being born.
For me it's like trying to read a very foreign language. The letters are beautiful but incomprehensible.
I probably shouldn't complain, because that's the way it is for very many people looking at astronomical pictures, I'm sure. The pictures are beautiful, but ultimately mysterious.
Ann
This is certainly a most impressive image. I can easily imagine that it is a treasure trove for professional astronomers.
For me, however, the image is beautiful, yet confusing. The picture tells me no story. Yes, I can understand that it shows me the presence of a lot of dust. Yes, I can understand that the dust has different temperatures and structures. But what do those temperatures and structures mean?
Yes, I can understand that redder gas is colder and greener gas is warmer. Yes, I can understand that cool - make that cold - dust is good for making stars. And yes, I can understand that dust that is warmer has probably already been affected by the heat and radiation of of hot stars.
But I can't see where in this image stars are being born. More frustratingly for me, I can think of no way to judge how massive the stars are that are being born.
[float=right][img]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/9d/Papyrus_Ani_curs_hiero.jpg/200px-Papyrus_Ani_curs_hiero.jpg[/img][/float]
For me it's like trying to read a very foreign language. The letters are beautiful but incomprehensible.
I probably shouldn't complain, because that's the way it is for very many people looking at astronomical pictures, I'm sure. The pictures are beautiful, but ultimately mysterious.
Ann