Starship Asterisk*

I thought so. The real focus is the sun. The secondary position in the ellipse, while it may be CALLED a "focus," does not require a body with mass, gravity, etc. for the elliptical orbit to function. Having rolled pennies in those giant funnel thingies in malls, I didn't think a 2nd object was necessary. Water goes down my bath tub drain without another hole at the other end, too.

I hope i understood your answer. thx

[quote="rriverstone"]

The person said that, if the sun is a focus of a planetary ellipse, something else has to be a focus on the other side of the ellipse. Intuitively, this feels wrong to me, probably because I play with yo yos and the like. The person said the phantom or ghost ellipse is dark matter, but i'm thinking it's just not there. SO? :/
[img]http://www.astrobio.nau.edu/~koerner/ast180/lectures/pic/cdrom/art_high-res/ch02/figure-02-08.jpg[/img][/quote]
The answer is contained within the posted diagram:
[color=#0000FF][size=150]There is NOT a symmetry between the two foci:[/size][/color]
equal areas are circumscribed in equal times [b][color=#FF0000]ONLY[/color][/b] as regards the sun focus.

So, I'm too ignorant to know if this person's idea is misguided, so I'm asking, to find out. The person said that, if the sun is a focus of a planetary ellipse, something else has to be a focus on the other side of the ellipse. Intuitively, this feels wrong to me, probably because I play with yo yos and the like. The person said the phantom or ghost ellipse is dark matter, but i'm thinking it's just not there. SO? :/
[img]http://www.astrobio.nau.edu/~koerner/ast180/lectures/pic/cdrom/art_high-res/ch02/figure-02-08.jpg[/img]